Our Review:

Sunset Pizzeria has a few locations. Hadn’t heard much about this place but I was in the area so I decided to give it a shot. Yelpers seem to like the place. I order a large pie, half cheese and half pepperoni.

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza from Sunset Pizzeria

Pepperoni pizza is usually my favorite a good staple, but I always like to try to have the plain cheese to really taste the quality of the plain pizza. After picking up my order I peek in the box and the pizza looks ok. Not great, but ok. Sometimes I open the box and I go “ohhh” when the pizza looks really good.

Cheese pizza from Sunset Pizzeria

Pepperoni pizza from Sunset Pizzeria

Digging in the pizza has a good taste but nothing special. It tastes like your basic neighborhood quality pizza place. The ingredients taste like quality ingredients and I’m left with a clean feeling after eating the pizza. It reminds me of Manhattan Pizza on the West Charleston. So if you’re a fan of that place then you might really like this pizza.

Flop of slice of pizza from Sunset Pizzeria

Bottom of crust of pizza from Sunset Pizzeria

I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here. Sunset has competition from Metro pizza and Jesse’s Pizza which are both just down the street. Metro has better pie and Jesse’s has better prices so it’s a bit of a tough sell for Sunset in my opinion.